Rated 4 out of 5 stars

i used to using this extension with my old laptop. but now it's not working properly with my Macbook Air M1 + Thunderbird 91 version. Always disable after restarting TB

Dear Fauzi, could you raise a bug on the official issue tracker? unfortunately I don't have a Mac to test.

Rated 3 out of 5 stars

Does not work without errors with version 60.9.1

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (3.5.3). 

I can't fix errors that you do not report officially, because I may not see them here on my own system - please report them on the SmartTemplates github or via the support tab.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

I love this addon

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.12). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

This addon works great! Special thanks to the developer for the ultra fast support; we had an issue with a minor bug and it was fixed in just a couple of hours. Definitely worth the money.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (3.0). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

RIESENKOMPLIMENT an die Entwickler dieses Projekts! Ihr habt es geschafft, dieses geniale Add-on nach TB 78 zu portieren.
Funktioniert bei mir tadellos!
Persönlich empfehle ich allen, eine Standardlizenz für WENIG Geld zu erwerben. Das Add-on ist es WERT! Und dahinter steht ein riesen Arbeitseinsatz.

Habe noch eine ANREGUNG: Ich habe ca. 10 HTML- Vorlagen unter "Verfassen" eingerichtet. Es wäre toll, wenn man alles auf ein Mal rüberkopieren könnte in den Tab "Antworten" und "Weiterleiten" – statt unter diesen beiden Tabs wieder alles eingeben zu müssen....
Lieber Gruss aus der Schweiz.

DANKE für die Idee! Funktioniert, habe es gerade gemacht.

Und noch eine ANREGUNG: Könntest Du bei den 3 Tabs noch einen Schalter "Trennlinie" einbauen? Bis jetzt helfe ich mir damit, dass ich eine leere HTML-Datei "hinzufüge" mit dem "Titel" "--------------------------". Das geht, ist aber etwas stümperhaft....

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (3.0). 

Gute Idee (I think). Um einen Eintrag zu übertragen, kannst Du ihn übrigens auf dem Ersten Tab markieren, dann auf den (die anderen Tab umschalten und Hinzufügen klicken,

Rated 2 out of 5 stars

I paid for the addon just tofind out I cannot use it because of an internal bug which made it imposible for me to switch accounts for outgoing messages. As this is a crucial option for me, the purchased add-on turned out useless for me. The developer communicated with me and could replicate the buggy behavior of the add-on but the problem has not been solved.

Follow-up 2020-07-13:
Yes it was reported on github as issue #37. The developer marked it as bug himself and as of today it is stil open.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.11.2).  This user has a previous review of this add-on.

is there a github issue attached to this particular one?

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Indispensable add-on for every hardcore email user and for them who want their email look unique and have differently designed templates for different accounts. Very good functionality and many options for customization, especially the licensed version. Frankly, it should be TB core functionality!
And the author, Axel Grude, is an extremely helpful dude.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.10.1). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

It is easy to use this Add-on. I was very much impressed by the quality and prompness of the support, in particular the fact that Axel Grude was even interested in improving the accessibility of ST4 for screenreader users.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.10.1). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Essential backup in order to make your emails look professional. Covers pretty much all situations and the author is going the extra mile supporting and improving his addon. Pro license highly recommended!

As long as the author still supports version 60 of TB I'll keep being a loyal user. Can't move away from v60 because they in their glorious wisdom decided to remove full theming support in later versions. Another topic...

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.9.1). 

I will try to keep support Thunderbird 60 as long as possible! In fact, I had a Postbox user complaining about incompatibility so I had to take down the compatibility flags on the variable page for 2.1 onwards - 2.9.2 will be "mostly" compatible with Postbox 5.5 (I haven't looked at the file template button integration yet). There is a github issue [#55] with some hot-patched versions for Postbox users

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

One of my favorite add-ons. Easy to use, excellent performance, and outstanding support! I highly recommend supporting this developer via subscription for this add-on.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.9). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

This is a great Add-on. It is expertly supported by the developer with patient friendly assistance throughout.
The Licence is reasonably priced and if you have any queries as to how you want to use the licence, to best suit your requirements, the developer will help and direct you in a professional manner.
Keep up the good work.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.7). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

We have been crazy about well-designed email templates not only for our own brands but also for our clients for as long as I can remember. Thunderbird is the top email client and with it comes this "next level" smart template add on. Axel is outstanding with exceptional knowledge and understanding of our requirements. Onwards and upwards.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.6). 

Rated 2 out of 5 stars

First installation and, without using it, a message in the bottom enjoigned me to buy an annual license.
It's probably a great tool but not for personal or educational use, I don't need it up to pay for it.
I'm disappointed because I've not seen that a paid extension (but I understand the author for that)

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.6). 

that's ok. at least 2 stars :)
All functionality runs as trial version for 28 days, and I needed to show this in some way. Writing Add-ons is a fulltime job at this stage, sorry I can't do it for free. I still believe it's a huge time saver and well worth the 5$. (4$ when on special offer)
PS: if you can't afford it at the moment I can make you a free trial license, just send me an email!

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Super Programm und super Service. Die Lizensgebühr finde ich absolut gerechtfertigt. Danke.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.6). 

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

I finally got a license today.
It's about time. Thanks for your work! :-)

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.6).  This user has a previous review of this add-on.

Thanks for supporting SmartTemplate!
People really have no idea how much work making and maintaining a good Add-on is. With your contribution, you are keeping this project alive; the more people support it, the cheaper and better it will get.

Rated 4 out of 5 stars

Good add-on. The basic functionality should be a part of Thunderbird by default, imo. Does require purchasing a license annually, but it's only a few dollars and I understand why the developer asks for it... Still, minus a star for non-free addon.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.6). 

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Unlike the great Stationery this is a PAID (non free) addon. It really should be clearly written in the description.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.5.2). 

it is - please see About this Add-on under the third heading "licensing". If you want to keep using Stationery, there is no problem as long as you stay behind using Thunderbird 60. I decided to fully monetize after it took several weeks of work to integrate the external HTML files and another several week to make my Add-on compatible with Thunderbird 68.

I also work on my Add-ons every day, providing free support and constantly improving them - had to already do a lot of unpaid work for v2.0 when Thunderbird 60 made a load of Add-ons incompatible. See: https://addons.thunderbird.net/en-US/thunderbird/addon/smarttemplate4/versions/

Also there are many many additional functions for extracting data from the replied to email in the Pro version. The Standard license is currently below 5$ for a whole year which is more than reasonable (renewals are cheaper).

SmartTemplate⁴ is "Free software" in the sense of that you can see all the source code and modify it to suit to your needs - only thing you can't do is create / publish a new version to compete with it. Free as in freedom, not beer.


Unlike a lot of other "free" software, SmartTemplate will never mine your data or sell your information for profit. If you prefer this way of monetization, feel free to use gmail, which reads your mails and tailors advertisements to your needs. I am only a single programmer but I find this behavior highly questionable.

Rated 5 out of 5 stars

Das AddOn ist bestimmt sehr gut, nur ich nutze es zu selten, um dafür zu bezahlen, bzw. ich weiß mir anders zu helfen.

Was mich aber wahnsinnig nervt: Sobald ich Smart Template deaktiviere oder ganz entferne und ich dann eine Email beantworte, ist der Hintergrund schwarz und die Schrift weiß und das lässt sich auch nicht ändern. Ich hab schon alles Mögliche probiert. Ich muss also die App aktiviert lassen und mir jedesmal den nervigen Hinweis wegen der Lizenz anschauen, ansonsten haben alle meine Antwort Emails schwarzen Hintergrund. Ich hab schon überlegt, ob das wohl ein Trick ist, die Lizenz zu kaufen...

Sobald ich dafür eine Lösung bekomme, gebe ich auch gerne die 5 Sterne...

EDIT: Danke für den Tip, das war die Lösung, deswegen jetzt auch die verdienten 5 Sterne

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.2.2). 

Bitte nimm doch mal den support link her. Auf allen unseren Support Seiten ist unten ein mail link - "Contact us via Email"
Das schwarz auf weiss hat aber nix mit SmartTemplate zu tun - Wahrscheinlich sind deine Standareinstellungen vermurkst, und in ST4 hast du Style settings drin die das korrigieren (?)

... Schau mal in Tb Optionen ➡ Verfassen ➡ HTML Optionen nach.. bitte den Rest per Email.

ich hatte einen Haufen Arbeit das Add-on für Thunderbird 68 kompatibel zu machen, da kann ich im Augenblick all die 1-Stern Reviews nicht wirklich brauchen. Aber meinen Benutzern helfe ich gerne weiter, dir muessen sich nur bei mir melden.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

Lesson 1 for developers: How to lose your user base and collect 1-star reviews: Start making payment compulsory. Instant success!

I had previously donated to this add-on but this is an instant removal. I only used this add-on for a few features in the end anyway.

Not so "Smart" move of the developer, there are many other ways...

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.2.2). 

... or you could have asked for a free license. Maybe the Add-on wasn't for you, after all, there are alternatives. I still hope your employer pays you something for your work.

I had to make a choice to either give up my day job and keep working on the Add-ons fulltime to keep them up to date with the crazy changes that Mozilla is pushing down or walk away and and leave my user base unsupported. This would mean SmartTemplate would stop working from end of August. I had thought (and tried) any other ways and you will see soon how many free (as in beer) Add-ons will stop working once Thunderbird 68 is released.

Necessary changes, just to make sure it keeps working for ESR 2019 / 2020:

I answered 100s of support emails, helped people with their HTML / CSS problems and implemented new features to solve their problems, completely pro bono.

I still know that Monetizing ST⁴ was the correct way forward, but asking for voluntary donations / only have Pro License users finance this work was not the correct way. Also, a payment of 45cent/month for that work is not unreasonable; but you will not get anything even from the most generous user if you do not ask - donations were an absolute exception. Most people believe we are paid by Mozilla or some other big corporation that has "spare cash" - this is not the case.

If you don't want to ask for a free license, I would recommend using the quicktext Add-on instead.

Rated 1 out of 5 stars

After restarting thunderbird a new tab opened with a flashing "buy license -33% off" icon and text saying this addon requires a license to work and the free / basic version has become a 14 days trial now.

The developer definitely put hard work into this addon. But the fact that the addon already had a PRO version before, which I didn't needed because I was satisfied with the basic options, makes this a bad move. Especially because it was from one day of another.

Last but not least, in my expectation the addons here(!) should work and not being time limited trial of paid software. But this line is not part of the rating just my extra two cents.

This review is for a previous version of the add-on (2.1.1). 

Thanks for your opinion. To keep using the "free as in beer" version perpetually you can roll back to version 2.0 (released last December), and disable Add-on updates. Unfortunately, I cannot update that version for Thunderbird 68 for free anymore, but as long as you stay with Thunderbird 60 you should be fine.

By the way it's not 33% off, the standard license costs 33% of the pro license (5 bucks, so with taxes around 50cents / month), so it's actually 66% off compared to "pro", I updated the website today to make that clearer - I know that's a lot of money, so it only makes send if you use the Add-on's functionality regularly and save enough time through it to justify such an expense. I believe if it saves you 1 minute per workday that would be a time saving of 20 minutes / month - if you earn less than 5 bucks / hour it would not be worth it.

The license is annual because Mozilla pushes down breaking changes (I had about 3 man-months of work to update my Add-ons for 2020) which will make sure that Add-ons will not work anymore without major work by the developers. The income from Pro-licenses did not reflect the amount of work (I would have ended up working well below minimum wage) and I do have a family I need to feed.

Transitioning my existing users was a necessary risk I had to take. Consider the 7 years of free support and development I supplied (since I took over development in 2012) as a parting gift. Unfortunately, I do not keep track so I cannot know how long an individual user has used it or how much they have benefited.

Also, discouraging Add-on authors by downvoting their work will not increase the amount of useful software on the site. Should you decide to remove SmartTemplate⁴ and go with the update to Thunderbird 68, you will notice a lot of "free as in beer" Add-ons go away. I am actively encouraging other developers to look into monetizing their Add-on in order not to walk away from an ever breaking platform. We can see what happened with many many useful Add-ons after Firefox 57 deprecated classic add-ons. We are just at the bottom of the totem pole.

PS: I see you switched to ReplyWithHeader, thanks for finding an alternative that works for you - you may as well mention it in your review text - I encourage all my users who prefer their developers to work for nothing to check it out!